Skip to main content
Debunking Old Wives' Tales: Feeding Cranky Babies

You are listening to Healthy Kids Zone:

Debunking Old Wives' Tales: Feeding Cranky Babies

Feb 06, 2017

Gas and fussiness are common in babies, but that does not necessarily mean something is wrong. Pediatrician Cindy Gellner, MD, debunks common myths about gassy and colicky babies, explaining why changing formulas too often and overfeeding can actually make digestive issues worse. Learn what parents should know about feeding schedules and when it is worth talking with your child’s pediatrician.

    This content was originally produced for audio. Certain elements, such as tone, sound effects, and music, may not fully capture the intended experience in textual representation. Therefore, the following transcription may have been modified for clarity. We recognize not everyone can access the audio podcast. However, for those who can, we encourage subscribing and listening to the original content for a more engaging and immersive experience.

    All thoughts and opinions expressed by hosts and guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views held by the institutions with which they are affiliated.

     


    Fact: Changing Formula Won’t Always Solve Gas or Fussiness

    As pediatricians, we often hear old wives' tales about cranky babies with feeding issues. "Babies who are cranky and don't sleep usually have gas, and the only way to get some relief is to change the formula."

    No! That can cause more issues. See, gas gets a bad rep. Many people think it's an evil condition that causes pain and misery, but the truth is, everyone produces gas in their large intestine because that's how bacteria processes what we eat. It's part of the digestive process, and if your baby is healthy, gaining weight, and pooping well, don't worry. It can cause some pain, but it shouldn't interfere with sleep issues.

    Crying babies increase the air they swallow, and so they have more gas, and crying increases the passage of gas by forcefully contracting the abdominal muscles. So, unless your baby has a true allergy or intolerance to a component of the formula and needs a special formula, don't play the formula-changing game. Changing formulas too often can actually cause more digestive issues than they can help with.

    Fact: Colic Doesn’t Always Mean Your Baby Is Hungry

    Number two: "Colicky babies are very hungry, and you've got to feed them more."

    Actually, feeding them more can make the problem worse. Overfeeding is not good. Many parents think that every time a baby cries, it must be from hunger, and that's just not true.

    Feeding your baby may reduce the crying, but only for a short time before the whole colic cycle begins again. Then, these hungry babies are too full, and then they end up spitting up, and gaining weight too fast, and they may be fussy because they're overeating and bloated. Remember how you felt the last time you ate more than you should have? Full, overstuffed, uncomfortable, and miserable.

    Feeding a colicky baby less, like every three to four hours, rather than every one to two, will give them time for their stomachs to empty and their feedings to be digested. Everyone will feel much better.

    When to Talk to Your Pediatrician About Ongoing Feeding Concerns

    So, if your baby is otherwise growing well, you really don't need to worry about their crying or their gas. If there are other feeding concerns, be sure to talk to your child's pediatrician about them and see if further investigation into these digestive issues is warranted.

    Feel Confident Caring for Your Newborn

    A collection of newborn-focused episodes from the HEALTHY KIDS ZONE podcast.

    NEW BABY? START HERE

    newborn with father

    Sorting Fact From Fiction So Parents Can Worry Less and Trust More.

    Young child brushing dark wet hair with a pink brush while sitting on a bed against a wood-paneled wall

    The Truth About Your Baby's Hair

    Will shaving your baby’s head make their hair grow back thicker? Does cutting their hair before their first birthday cause bad hair? And can eating carrots or bread crusts actually make your child’s hair curly?

    Listen (2 mins) / Read
    Woman holding an infant on her shoulder, the baby looking toward the camera

    Burping Babies After Feeding

    Many parents worry that if their baby does not burp after a feeding, they will end up with gas, colic, or an upset stomach. Learn when burping babies may help and when it does not.

    Listen (2 mins) / Read
    two young children sitting poolside in the sun

    Summer Safety Tips for Your Kids

    Summer fun comes with its fair share of advice, but not all of it holds up. Learn how to keep your kids safe with tips rooted in real science, not old wives' tales.

    Listen (2 mins) / Read
    father feeding baby food to toddler

    What You Should and Shouldn't Be Feeding Your Baby

    Many feeding habits are rooted in outdated advice rather than current science. Learn more about common baby feeding myths and what today's medical experts recommend instead.

    Listen (4 mins) / Read
    Little baby girl chewing a toy on the floor.

    Common Misconceptions About Your Baby's Teething

    Many parents link fevers, diarrhea, and even ear pulling to teething. Learn how to tell when your baby's fussiness might be connected to more than just new teeth.

    Listen (3 mins) / Read
    young girl looking through donuts

    Why Your Child Isn’t Actually on a Sugar High

    For decades, parents have blamed sugar for their children's wild energy, but research tells a different story. Learn smart strategies for managing sugar in your child's diet while promoting healthy habits.

    Listen (3 mins) / Read
    teenager girl with face acne

    Childhood Acne

    In the battle against your child's acne, parents often wonder about the efficacy of treatments. Learn five realities and misconceptions surrounding the treatment of childhood and teenage acne.

    Listen (3 mins) / Read
    mother helping smiling laughing toddler walk

    Toddlers

    Many parents have heard traditional beliefs or old wives' tales surrounding raising children. Learn about the veracity of these toddler tales, providing clarity on what holds and what remains a myth in the realm of child development.

    Listen (4 mins) / Read
    mother helping child with diabetetic glucose shot

    Childhood Diabetes

    You have probably heard the old wives’ tale, “Do not let your child eat sugar, or they will get diabetes.” Learn the common myths and what parents should know regarding their child's diabetes.

    Listen (5 mins) / Read