Nov 6, 2017

Dr. Gellner: As much as we parents would like, we can't bubble wrap our kids. I'll discuss some old wives tales about kids and their environment today on The Scope. I'm Dr. Cindy Gellner.

Announcer: Remember that one thing, that one person told you that one time about what you should or shouldn't do with raising your kids? Find out if it's true or not. This is Debunking Old Wives Tales with Dr. Cindy Gellner on The Scope.

Dr. Gellner: There are several times in the child's life where parents are going to be very concerned about the effects of their immediate environment on their health. For example, parents often think that newborns are fragile and shouldn't be taken out of the house for several weeks. That's a myth. You will have a serious case of cabin fever if you do that.

Unless your child has special health care needs, go ahead, take them out into the world. There are actually more germs inside a house than outside, and the good thing is, babies have the bonus of antibodies from their mom they got before they were even born. Obviously, you'll want to keep them away from huge crowds where they could be sneezed or coughed on and away from other kids who are sick.

Speaking of sick kids, if you've got one, the hard and fast rule is that they need to be confined to bed until they're 100% better, right? Wrong. If they really don't feel good, they're going to want to rest of course, because they're tired and their bodies are trying to heal. However, if they just have a cold, they're not crying in pain and they've got the energy and they're bored of lying around, let them get up and play. Studies show that being active while sick may actually help them recover more quickly.

I can't tell you how many times I've heard from parents, "My child got sick because the weather changed. It got colder. He went out into the rain. He didn't wear a hat or a coat." This is one big old wives tale that keeps getting passed down despite it being far from the truth. The only thing your child will get if they go out in the rain is wet. The only thing they will get if they go out without a hat or a coat is cold. They won't get sick. Cold symptoms are caused by viruses, not weather changes. There is something called vasomotor rhinitis and that's when your nose runs if it's cold outside. But that's your child's body's response to the cold temperature and it goes away when your child comes inside for a bit. It has nothing to do with the respiratory viruses that cause days of runny noses. Your child's immune system will work no matter what the weather is like.

Finally, everyone worries that their child will get sick if they play in the dirt or if your home isn't "Good Housekeeping" sparkling clean. Actually the opposite is true. The hygiene theory tells us that little kids who are exposed to dirt, other kids whether they are older siblings or daycare friends, and even animal dander seem to have stronger immune systems as they grow up. They have less allergies and asthma and even a lower risk of autoimmune diseases like multiple sclerosis when they're adults. So yeah, we don't want kids to go without baths for days on end, but a little dirt, some playmates, and even a furry friend can actually help your child stay healthy in the long run.

Announcer: Want The Scope delivered straight to your inbox? Enter your email address at and click "Sign me up" for updates of our latest episodes. The Scope Radio is a production of University of Utah Health Sciences.

For Patients