The Pacifier Dilemma: When to Start, When to Stop, and How to Transition
The Pacifier Dilemma: When to Start, When to Stop, and How to Transition
As a parent, it may seem like pacifiers are always a battle—whether you’re trying to get your child to take one or to take one away.
Pacifiers can be helpful to babies, who are born with the need to suck to eat and drink. Sucking can also be soothing or calming to some babies.
If you’re debating about whether to give your child a pacifier, consider these things:
- Pacifier use is not recommended before your newborn is 3-4 weeks old so they can establish breastfeeding skills.
- Offering a pacifier during sleep can reduce the risk of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS).
- There’s a lower risk of developing finger or thumb sucking habits.
- The American Academy of Pediatrics and the American Academy of Family Physicians recommends weaning children from pacifiers by the age of 18 months to prevent otitis media.
- Extended pacifier use can have adverse dental effects.
Pacifiers and Your Child’s Teeth
"Some children benefit from the psychological security that a pacifier brings, and that’s a good thing," says James Bekker, DMD, a pediatric dentist at the University of Utah School of Dentistry. "Teeth can be straightened, but psychological development is very important."
Research shows that children using a pacifier at age 3 or older have a higher chance of developing anterior open bite than those who do not use a pacifier. Continued use can also lead to posterior crossbite.
"The harm is usually in creating an 'open bite' where the front teeth don't meet, making biting foods difficult," Bekker says. "Pacifiers also can cause a narrow palate and sometimes a posterior cross-bite. These are conditions that can be addressed with interceptive orthodontics."
To avoid such problems, it’s encouraged to wean pacifier use by the time a baby is 18 months old.
"When the pacifier is stopped, the bite naturally starts to correct, so the earlier the habit is stopped, the better the outcome and less treatment required," Bekker says.
Pacifier Weaning
Most children will stop their sucking habits on their own. However, this is not always the case, and your child might need some encouragement. It’s time to start thinking of pacifier weaning around 18 months.
“Speech development is so important after one year,” says Elizabeth R. Smith, MD, a pediatrician at University of Utah Health. “I typically encourage parents to transition to only using the pacifier for sleep, so that when the child is awake, the pacifier doesn’t get in the way of making speech sounds.”
When it's time to give up the pacifier, it’s important to know the comfort it can bring to a child. This is a good opportunity to transfer that emotion to another object.
You can do this by:
- Limiting pacifier use to naps and sleep.
- Offering another security replacement such as a stuffed animal or blanket.
- Praising your child when they don’t use their pacifier, such as through daily rewards or star charts.
- Keeping your child distracted or busy to get their mind off the pacifier.
And when you’re ready to ditch the pacifier completely, make it special for your little one.
“Sometimes this can involve a ‘pacifier party’ where the toddler gets a surprise to replace their pacifier,” Smith says. “Some parents will also let their child ‘trade in’ their pacifiers for a toy of their choice, which is a fun way of letting them be involved in decision making.”
If you have any concerns about pacifier use, talk with your pediatrician. Pacifier weaning is not always easy, but help is always available.
Learn More From Our Specialists
The Basics: Your Daughter's Painful Urination
Is your young daughter complaining about painful urination when using the bathroom? Learn about the most common causes of pain or irritation in the vagina or vulva, how to prevent them, and treatment options.
What Kind of Burn Is It, and Does My Kid Need the ER?
Learn the differences between chemical, electrical, and thermal burns in kids, and why first-degree burns can be managed at home while third-degree burns should always be treated as a medical emergency.
A First Aid Guide to Playground Injuries
Playgrounds equal fun, but also falls, scrapes, and the occasional broken bone. Learn which common playground injuries need a Band-Aid versus a trip to urgent care or the pediatric emergency room.
What Parents Need to Know About Constipation in Kids
Constipation is one of the most common concerns parents bring to their pediatrician. Learn about the causes of constipation in kids and practical tips to help your child have softer, more comfortable bowel movements.
Managing Asthma in Children
Asthma can be a daunting diagnosis for parents, but it can be managed effectively with the right knowledge and tools. Learn how to recognize asthma symptoms, the importance of treatment adherence, and strategies to prevent exacerbations.
How to Tell Common Childhood Rashes Apart
Measles is just one of many childhood rashes that can look alarming. Learn about the most common viral rashes in kids—from measles and chickenpox to scarlet fever, roseola, and hand, foot, and mouth disease.
More Answers to Your Questions on Keeping Your Kid Healthy and Happy
Latest trends and issues in children's health with pediatrician Dr. Cindy Gellner.
