Skip to main content
Choosing the Right Sunscreen: Why Minerals Matter More Than SPF

You are listening to Health Library:

Choosing the Right Sunscreen: Why Minerals Matter More Than SPF

Jun 04, 2024

SPF stands for "sunburn protection factor" and indicates how long one can stay in the sun without getting burned. Despite common belief, the SPF number alone may not be the most crucial factor to consider when selecting sunscreen. Doug Grossman, MD, explains the SPF sunscreen index and underscores the significance of active ingredients, particularly minerals like zinc or titanium, in providing effective protection against harmful UV rays. Learn how to ensure you are adequately shielded from the sun's damaging effects.

    This content was originally produced for audio. Certain elements, such as tone, sound effects, and music, may not fully capture the intended experience in textual representation. Therefore, the following transcription may have been modified for clarity. We recognize not everyone can access the audio podcast. However, for those who can, we encourage subscribing and listening to the original content for a more engaging and immersive experience.

    All thoughts and opinions expressed by hosts and guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views held by the institutions with which they are affiliated.

     


    What Is SPF?

    Interviewer: Every time you buy a bottle of sunscreen, you get an SPF protection factor, but have you ever stopped to think, what does that number actually mean? What is SPF? Have you heard about the trend to move away from SPF as a way of rating how effective sun creams are? We'll discuss all that next on The Scope.

    Dr. Doug Grossman, at Huntsman Cancer Institute. SPF in sunscreen: what exactly does SPF stand for?

    Dr. Grossman: SPF is sunburn protection factor. What this indicates is how much longer you can stay out in the sun and not get burned.

    Interviewer: So what does the number mean then? Is that like...?

    Dr. Grossman: Well, for instance, if something is an SPF 30, that means that if normally you will get burned in one hour in the sun, you can potentially stay out for 30 hours, wearing that product.

    Interviewer: Oh, really? Is that for real? It seems...

    Dr. Grossman: And get the same amount of sun exposure.

    Interviewer: That seems pretty crazy that you can actually stay out without applying for 30 hours.

    Practicality and Limitations of SPF in Sunscreen Use

    Dr. Grossman: The problem is that these numbers come from a specific type of testing that's done under controlled circumstances. In reality, I don't think you really could stay out that long.

    Interviewer: Sure, sure. But if I am put on an SPF of 30, I could stay out for a couple of hours, fairly confidently, I would think.

    Dr. Grossman: Well, again, this relates to sunburn protection: a product can protect you against sunburn but still allow other UV rays to come through and cause these other types of damage, which we know are important for skin cancer. So the SPF again just relates to the sunburn protection factor, and so you can still be outside and not get a sunburn, but still be getting that exposure that can be damaging later.

    Choosing Effective Sunscreen

    Interviewer: So, if you are wearing sunscreen, you mentioned earlier that there are two different types: there's a chemical and a mineral, and the mineral is better. What SPF would you recommend?

    Dr. Grossman: So what I tell patients is that the SPF factor does not really matter. What's important is to have those active ingredients, and if you have zinc or titanium, one of these minerals in the product, it's going to work much better, and you almost don't have to reapply it, unless you are really getting wet and toweling it off.

    Interviewer: So the SPF is not as important as the ingredients.

    Dr. Grossman: Right, in my opinion. Actually, there will be new guidelines coming out from the FDA that minimize the number, the SPF number, and stress more the quality of the product.

    Interviewer: Well, that's interesting.

     

    updated: June 4, 2024
    originally published: August 19, 2014

    Learn More From Our Specialists

    young boy sitting by side of swimming pool

    What Does Drowning Look Like?

    Half of the children who drown do so within 25 yards of their parents. Knowing what drowning really looks like could help you recognize an emergency and act before it is too late.

    Listen (5 mins) / Read
    woman experiencing heat stroke

    Can I Build Tolerance to Heat?

    Feeling wiped out by summer heat at the start of the season—but just fine by August? Learn the science behind heat conditioning, the risks of pushing too far, and what it takes to build heat resilience safely and effectively.

    Listen (4 mins) / Read
    woman sitting outside in the sun with heatstroke

    Heatstroke—ER or Not?

    When it is dangerously hot outside and someone starts acting strangely or passes out, it could be more than just dehydration. Learn cooling strategies, when to call 911, and how to protect the most vulnerable in your community.

    Listen (9 mins) / Read
    two young children sitting poolside in the sun

    Debunking Old Wives' Tales: Summer Safety Tips for Your Kids

    Summer fun comes with its fair share of advice—but not all of it holds up. Learn how to keep your kids safe with tips rooted in real science, not old wives' tales.

    Listen (3 mins) / Read
    young girl with sunscreen on face at the beach

    Preventing and Treating Sunburns in Kids

    Sunburns are not just uncomfortable; they are a sign of real skin damage that starts in childhood and can increase the risk of skin cancer later in life. Learn how to prevent sunburns and why babies and fair-skinned children need extra protection.

    Listen (7 mins) / Read
    woman wearing sunglasses sitting in swimming pool

    How the Sun Damages Your Eyes—and How to Prevent It

    You know the sun can damage your skin, but what about your eyes? Learn how to protect your vision with smart, everyday habits—no dark tint required.

    Listen (5 mins) / Read
    various sunscreen with different spa

    Choosing the Right Sunscreen: Why Minerals Matter More Than SPF

    SPF stands for "sunburn protection factor" and indicates how long one can stay in the sun without getting burned. Despite common belief, the SPF number alone may not be the most crucial factor to consider when selecting sunscreen.

    Listen (2 mins) / Read