Skip to main content
Debunking Old Wives' Tales: 4 Myths About Toddlers

You are listening to Healthy Kids Zone:

Debunking Old Wives' Tales: 4 Myths About Toddlers

Jan 29, 2024

Many parents have heard traditional beliefs or old wives' tales surrounding raising children, but are any of them true? Will wearing shoes accelerate a toddler's ability to walk? Does teething make your child sick? Pediatrician Cindy Gellner, MD, talks about the veracity of these toddler tales, providing clarity on what holds true, and what remains a myth in the realm of child development.

    This content was originally produced for audio. Certain elements, such as tone, sound effects, and music, may not fully capture the intended experience in textual representation. Therefore, the following transcription may have been modified for clarity. We recognize not everyone can access the audio podcast. However, for those who can, we encourage subscribing and listening to the original content for a more engaging and immersive experience.

    All thoughts and opinions expressed by hosts and guests are their own and do not necessarily reflect the views held by the institutions with which they are affiliated.

     


    How many times have you been told, "Don't do that or your baby will have some horrible problem"? As a pediatrician, whenever a conversation starts with, "My grandmother told me," we know there's a good chance that an old wives' tale is the next part of the sentence. Yes, sometimes, we cringe or giggle or roll our eyes. That's because old wives' tales are just that: old. Old knowledge. It's an oral tradition dating way back before Dr. Google. But with all our medical knowledge now, why do some people still cling to these stories? Some probably have survived through the ages because they offer comforting advice about the experiences we all share, have little control over, and usually worry about—especially when it comes to kids.

    Fact: Wearing Shoes Does Not Help Babies Walk Sooner

    The first old wives' tale: wearing shoes will help a baby to walk sooner. Wrong. The opposite is true in this case. Keeping the baby barefoot can actually help to strengthen the foot muscles and help your child learn to walk earlier.

    For those learning how to be mobile, I like the soft-soled shoes that are kind of like moccasins. They're functional yet fashionable. For those crazy and fast toddlers who are walking and running, they need comfortable shoes that fit well. They shouldn't be too rigid. Don't go out and buy expensive designer shoes either. Your little one will outgrow those in weeks. Shoes should conform to the shape of the child's feet, but still provide a little extra room for growth.

    Fact: Walkers Do Not Help Babies Walk Sooner

    "A walker will help the baby learn to walk sooner." Again, not true. Those babies who are plopped down in a walker actually learn to sit, crawl, and walk later than kids who have to learn these skills on their own if they want to get around.

    More importantly, baby walkers are dangerous. Nearly 14,000 injuries are treated in emergency rooms every year as a result of walkers, and 34 children have died since 1973 because of baby walkers. I have seen kids who were in walkers who got too close to the stairs, and down will go baby, walker, and all. It's usually not a good outcome. The American Academy of Pediatrics actually recommended a ban on mobile infant walkers in the United States. I tell parents, if they want something like this for their baby to keep them entertained and contained, use an ExerSaucer.

    Fact: Thumb Sucking After Age 5 Can Cause Buck Teeth

    "Thumb sucking causes buck teeth." True and false. Thumb sucking often begins before birth and generally continues until age five. If your child stops before the age of four, their teeth should be okay. If they continue after age five, when the gum, jaws, and permanent teeth begin their most significant growth, that's when kids get buck teeth. Usually, elementary school peer pressure helps stop this habit.

    Fact: Teething Does Not Cause Lower Resistance to Infections

    Finally, the one I hear most of all is, "Teething causes a fever, runny nose, and diarrhea." Big false. Teething does not cause any of those. It doesn't cause a fever, sleep problems, diarrhea, diaper rash, or lowered resistance to any infection. It probably doesn't cause that much crying either. If your baby develops a fever while teething, the fever is caused by something else. Most likely a virus, as babies who are teething are building up their immune systems and catching any cold that comes their way.

    So next time someone tries to offer you some "helpful advice" about your baby, if it seems odd, ask your pediatrician.

     

    updated: January 29, 2024
    originally published: May 30, 2016

    Sorting fact from fiction so parents can worry less and trust more

    DEBUNKING OLD WIVES' TALES

    What That Smell Means: A Parent's Guide to Child Odors

    Kids can be messy, sweaty, and occasionally smelly. But some odors may point to a medical issue instead of just needing a bath. Learn what is usually harmless, what simple fixes may help at home, and when certain smells could signal infections, constipation, diabetes, or other concerns worth checking out.

    Read / Listen

    When Does My Child Need to Go to the ER for a Nose Injury?

    Does your child's nose seem to be a trauma magnet, constantly getting bumped, bruised, and bloodied? It is pretty typical for kids to hurt their noses as they play and explore. Learn when you should treat your child's injured nose at home and when it is time to go to the doctor.

    Read / Listen

    How to Treat Your Child's Cold Sore

    Cold sores are common in adults, but they can surprise parents when they appear in children. Caused by the herpes simplex virus, these painful blisters often return during illness, stress, or fatigue. Learn when to ask your doctor about prescription treatment.

    Read / Listen

    Is Your Child Peeing Too Often? Frequent Urination in Young Children Explained

    Your preschooler suddenly needs the bathroom every few minutes—but seems otherwise fine. While alarming for parents, this common phase is often harmless and linked to stress, routine changes, or bladder habits rather than disease. Learn the warning signs that deserve medical attention and how reassurance often becomes the best treatment.

    Read / Listen

    Treating Your Child's "Barking Cough" at Home

    Has your child got a bad cough that almost sounds like a seal? Hearing a child with croup is concerning to any parent. Learn about at-home treatments, how a pediatrician can help, and when it is time to go to the ER.

    Read / Listen

    My Child Has Night Terrors—What Can I Do?

    It can be hard to watch your child have night terrors—when they scream and cry inconsolably at night. Although night terrors usually stop eventually, learn to recognize signs that it may be something more serious, and when you should take your child to the doctor.

    Read / Listen

    How to Make Your Child Comfortable While They Recover From the Flu

    If your child comes down with the flu, there is, unfortunately, not much you can do except make them comfortable and wait for the virus to run its course. Learn what foods your child should eat, how much water they should drink, their medications, and when they can go back to school.

    Read / Listen