Negative Reactions to Starting A New DietFeb 26, 2014
Extreme cravings, headaches, fatigue, low energy, brain fog, gas and bloating. Have you ever experienced a situation where you start a new diet and instead of feeling better, you feel worse? Registered dietitian Staci McIntosh talks about the adjustment period and some of the symptoms you might be experiencing when first changing to a new diet. She also offers words of advice on how to keep with a new diet, even if the results may be making you feel not so great at the beginning.
Scot: Sure, so if you're eating a lot of fast food all the time and then all of a sudden you're going to raw vegetables and fruits?
Staci McIntosh: Expect a couple of weeks.
Scot: That's going to be kind of nasty.
Staci McIntosh: It's going to take some adjustment for sure.
Scot: All right so that answers the what's going on question, what about some specific symptoms? So for me I feel like I tend to get a little gassy or bloaty when I start eating what I consider healthy, and to define that you know like healthy meat alternatives, chicken, turkey, fish, fruits, vegetables, what's happening there?
Staci McIntosh: So a lot of times our gut is populated with bacteria . . . Well, it's always populated with bacteria, and it gets specific to the types of foods that we're eating. When you change that and you're eating more fruits or vegetables then the type of bacteria that populates your gut is going to change with it, and that takes an adjustment period, and that will result in gas, and bloating, and a change of the population of that bacteria.
Scot: If you already said this, I'm sorry, but so the bacteria probably helps you digest, and you need to get the right kind for the food.
Staci McIntosh: Exactly, we all have bacteria in our gut, and it's part of our happy gut flora, and there's a healthy population of a variety of bacteria, and then there's not so much of a healthy population.
Scot: So you've got to get rid of the fast food bacteria and get some fresh fruit bacteria in there?
Staci McIntosh: You're introducing the good bacteria as you eat more fruits and vegetables, and then that's going to start changing the whole flora.
Scot: What about constipation and diarrhea is that the same thing going on there?
Staci McIntosh: Some of it will be. Some of it may be that you've gone from a low fiber diet to a pretty high fiber diet without a transition period, and without enough water during that time. So I always recommend that if someone's going from a pretty low fiber diet, so the average American eats 13 grams of fiber a day, and the average recommendation is between 25 and 38 grams a day.
Scot: Wow so almost half.
Staci McIntosh: So we're a pretty low fiber community in general so if we're going from a low fiber diet to a high fiber diet, we need a little transition period, and we need to increase the amount of water and activity that we're doing so that it helps get things healthy and not result in constipation.
Scot: Is that another enzyme issue?
Staci McIntosh: It's not an enzyme issue. Because we don't digest fiber so there's no enzyme to digest fiber, but it's just a matter of the fiber sucks in water and that's what helps make an easier stool to pass, but if you don't have the extra water for it to suck in then it becomes constipation.
Scot: All right, what about like brain fog? I feel like when I start my new diet sometimes I get brain fog. I'm not as sharp as I used to be. What could be going on there?
Staci McIntosh: You know I would have to find out more about what you were eating before and then what you changed to. I would expect, I expect to hear those kind of questions sometimes when I have a patient who's going to a low carbohydrate diet, or going to a paleo diet, or going to some extreme diet where they don't have enough carbohydrates intake, and then it will make you feel like a brain fog because you don't have enough basic glucose in the brain.
Scot: So you can eliminate too many carbohydrates?
Staci McIntosh: Absolutely.
Scot: What about fatigue and low energy is that a carbohydrate issue again?
Staci McIntosh: Yeah your basic, your primary source of fuel for every cell in the body is glucose.
Scot: Could it be just more calories could be the solution for something like that or does it need to be carbs?
Staci McIntosh: It needs to be glucose, you're going to use glucose for your brain, you're going to use glucose for energy for every cell in the body, and you can get that glucose from breaking down glycerol from fatty acids, or from turning amino acids into glucose, but that's just another step that your body has to go through.
Scot: Got you.
Staci McIntosh: So if it has available glucose then you have available energy for the cells.
Scot: What about headaches what could cause that if you're changing from one philosophy of eating to another?
Staci McIntosh: A lot of different things. So sometimes if people are going into using a lot of non-nutritive sugar replacements, so saccharin, aspartame, all those type things. If you would normally drink soda and then you go to a diet soda that can give people headaches a lot of times, and also if you're going to a really low carbohydrate diet you're brain uses glucose, and every cell in your brain uses glucose, and it wants glucose, and if you don't have enough glucose available if you're on either a very low calorie diet, you're not getting enough fluids, or you're not getting enough glucose regardless of the calorie amount that would be a typical recipe for a headache.
Scot: Okay, how about extreme cravings? Now all of a sudden I want everything that's not good for me anymore.
Staci McIntosh: That's human nature.
Scot: Is that what that is?
Staci McIntosh: Yeah that's human nature. As soon as you say you can never have chocolate again that's all you're going to think about.
Scot: Yeah, so that's why it's probably good to maybe allow yourself a little.
Staci McIntosh: That's why everything in moderation.
Scot: A little taste, all right. What about going through withdrawals of things like caffeine, or sugar, are there withdrawal symptoms to those types of things?
Staci McIntosh: Absolutely, when you look at someone's MRI scan, for example, and you look at the result that it has on the brain for sugar versus nicotine it's the same area of the brain that gets stimulated so it does trigger, certainly not an addiction like nicotine would, but it's triggering the same areas of the brain so you can experience those withdrawals.
Scot: All right and some headaches might be caused by getting rid of the bad stuff and you're actually going through withdrawals, like . . . wow.
Staci McIntosh: Sure.
Scot: When somebody goes on a new diet what words of advice do you have for them to get through this process, because I imagine some of these things actually stop people from eating better?
Staci McIntosh: Absolutely, I say one step at a time, don't change everything overnight, if you have gained excess weight you gained it one gram at a time let's think about losing it one gram at time not changing everything all at once, and keeping in mind that eating is a basic enjoyment of life. If you're changing to a diet that is really not that enjoyable then why do that? Why not just start on something that you plan to do the rest of your life because it's healthy, and it's enjoyable, and you and your entire family can do it?
Announcer: We're your daily dose of science, conversation, medicine. This is The Scope, University of Utah Health Science Radio.